MLB Picks · September 26, 2026
St. Louis Cardinals vs Milwaukee Brewers
Strong Lean
Brewers ML
-163
70
/ 100
Starting Pitchers
St. Louis Cardinals · Away
Quinn Mathews (LHP)
Milwaukee Brewers · Home
Dustin May (RHP)
AI Analysis
Milwaukee is the superior team on almost every dimension — 101-59 record, the best in this slate, with 8-2 in last 10 on a W3 streak. Dustin May (ERA 4.67, WHIP 1.32) is not elite but holds an edge over Mathews (ERA 3.65 but only 44.1 IP — thin sample for a LHP). The Cardinals' offense is among the worst on this slate recently (3.1 R/G last 10, .574 OPS last 10, multiple ❄️ key hitters — Walker, Burleson, Winn, Herrera all cold). MIL hits .246/.707 vs LHP which is respectable and their lineup features quality bats across the board (Turang 🔥, Chourio, Bauers, Contreras). Despite the pitching score being limited by May's ERA, MIL's dominant team quality and STL's offensive collapse support a play.
Concerns
- •Dustin May's 4.67 ERA limits pitching score — not a dominant arm
- •Mathews' 3.65 ERA is in a small sample (44.1 IP) — may be legitimately good
- •MIL offense hits worse vs LHP (.707 vs .758 vs RHP) — slight split disadvantage
- •-163 price demands strong confidence
- •STL has some positive recent performers (Church 🔥, Fermín 🔥)
Factor Breakdown